Underpricing new businesses may feel like a safe way to attract customers, but it can leave every sale too weak to support owner pay, overhead, reliable delivery, and reinvestment. A full schedule or rising order count doesn’t guarantee a healthy business when too little money remains from each transaction.
The problem often develops slowly. You make sales, stay busy, and collect revenue, yet unexpected expenses create stress and paying yourself remains difficult. Understanding why this happens helps you set a sustainable first price, recognize weak margins, manage discounts, and adjust rates without making a sudden leap.
Why Do New Businesses Underprice Without Realizing It?
New businesses often underprice because low rates appear to reduce the customer’s risk. When you lack a long track record, you may use price to compensate for limited reviews, a small portfolio, or uncertainty about demand.
You may also assume competitors know something you don’t. Copying their prices feels safer than making your own decision, but you rarely know their costs, profit targets, capacity, or reasons for choosing a particular number. An established competitor may operate at a lower cost, earn money from related services, or be using an outdated rate. Matching that price can place your younger business at an immediate disadvantage.
Cost-plus pricing can create a similar problem when the calculation leaves out parts of the work. Materials and visible labor are easy to count, but administration, revisions, payment processing, software, packaging, delivery, sales calls, and owner time also consume resources. The habit of underpricing new businesses often begins with an incomplete cost estimate rather than a deliberate decision to accept low margins.
How Do Low Prices Damage More Than Revenue?
Low prices reduce the amount available to cover mistakes, slow periods, replacements, support, and growth. Your business can generate revenue and still struggle because revenue isn’t the same as usable profit.
Pricing has a direct effect on operating profit. McKinsey’s analysis of large-company income statements found that a one percent price increase, with sales volume remaining stable, could produce an eight percent increase in operating profit. The economics of a new business will differ, but the principle still applies: small pricing gaps can have a much larger effect after costs are paid.
Thin margins also increase cash pressure. A CB Insights review of hundreds of venture-backed business shutdowns found that running out of capital was the most common final cause, with unsustainable unit economics among the underlying problems. Underpricing isn’t the sole cause of cash trouble, but a weak contribution from every sale gives you less room to absorb delays, cost increases, refunds, and uneven demand.
Your delivery quality can suffer as well. If one project doesn’t generate enough money, you need more projects to reach the same income target. That workload can reduce preparation time, limit customer support, and delay improvements. Customers may see a low price, but they eventually experience the operational strain behind it.
How Can You Tell If Your Prices Are Too Low?
Your prices are probably too low when greater sales create greater pressure without producing stronger cash reserves or dependable owner pay. The clearest warning signs appear in your workload, margins, customer behavior, and ability to fund routine business needs.
Start by looking at what remains after each sale. If the remaining amount can’t contribute meaningfully to overhead and profit, the price isn’t supporting the business. A growing order book should improve your financial position rather than deepen your dependence on the next payment. Being busy and being profitable are separate conditions.
Customer behavior offers another signal. You may receive little resistance to every proposal, close nearly every price-sensitive lead, or attract buyers who focus mainly on discounts. Easy acceptance isn’t always proof of underpricing, but a pattern with no negotiation or comparison can show that your price sits below the value customers perceive.
Operational symptoms matter too. Watch for unpaid administrative work, repeated scope expansion, limited money for tools, and a constant need to accept new work before finishing existing commitments. If taking a short break threatens cash flow, your prices may not include enough margin to support normal downtime. A sustainable rate should fund the full business, not just the visible task.
Should You Use Cost-Plus, Competitor-Based, Or Value-Based Pricing?
You should use costs and competitor rates as boundaries, then use customer value to choose your position within a reasonable range. Relying on only one method can hide important information.
Cost-plus pricing starts with the total cost of producing and delivering an offer, then adds a markup. It gives you a useful minimum and forces you to identify direct labor, materials, and overhead. Its weakness is that your costs don’t tell you what the result is worth to the customer. A low-cost service can still solve an expensive problem, and a costly product can still offer limited customer value.
Competitor-based pricing helps you understand what buyers already see in the market. Use it to compare package size, quality, support, guarantees, turnaround time, and customer type. Don’t copy a competitor’s number without comparing those differences. A competitor’s price is market information, not an instruction.
Value-based pricing considers the outcome, convenience, risk reduction, time saved, and service experience the customer receives. You still need to cover all costs, but you don’t stop the calculation there. Ask why customers buy, what alternatives cost them, and which parts of your offer influence their decision. This method connects price to the result you provide rather than your confidence level as a new owner.
How Do You Calculate A Sustainable First Price?
A sustainable first price covers the full cost of delivery, contributes to overhead, pays for your time, and leaves a planned profit. It also fits the customer group and market position you intend to serve.
Begin with direct costs tied to each sale. These can include labor, materials, packaging, shipping, transaction fees, subcontractors, and customer-specific software. Add the time spent before and after delivery, including consultations, planning, communication, invoicing, revisions, and support. If you sell services, overlooking non-billable time can make an hourly rate appear profitable when it isn’t.
Allocate a fair share of recurring overhead to each sale. Rent, insurance, accounting, equipment, marketing, subscriptions, licenses, and professional services still need funding when a customer doesn’t see them. Estimate a realistic sales volume rather than assuming every available hour or unit will sell. Your break-even price should work under normal conditions, not only during a perfect month.
Add a profit amount after covering those costs. Profit funds reserves, replacement equipment, new offers, training, hiring, and owner returns beyond basic compensation. Compare the result with customer value and market alternatives, then adjust the package if the required price feels difficult to support. Reducing unnecessary scope is often safer than cutting the price and delivering the same work for less.
How Can You Raise Prices Without Losing Early Customers?
You can raise prices with less disruption by improving the offer, communicating the change plainly, and separating existing commitments from future purchases. You don’t need to surprise every customer or change every rate at once.
Begin with new customers. Test the revised price on incoming proposals, track acceptance, and record the questions buyers ask. A few declined offers don’t prove the increase failed, especially if the customers who accept produce healthier margins. Measure revenue, profit, delivery time, and sales conversion together rather than judging the change by sales count alone.
For existing customers, explain what is changing, when it takes effect, and what the price includes. Keep the message brief and avoid apologizing for operating a sustainable business. You can honor signed agreements, provide reasonable notice for recurring work, or offer a limited transition period. Don’t promise a permanent old rate unless the arrangement still meets your financial requirements.
You can also revise packaging instead of applying one flat increase. Create service levels with clear differences in access, speed, customization, quantity, or support. Customers who need fewer features can choose a smaller package, and customers who value convenience can choose a higher tier. This preserves choice without forcing you to discount the full offer.
When Do Discounts Help Or Hurt A New Business?
Discounts help when they support a specific goal and preserve an acceptable margin. They hurt when they become the default method for closing sales or compensate for an unclear value proposition.
A useful discount has defined boundaries. It can reward a larger order, faster payment, longer commitment, quieter delivery period, or reduced scope. The business receives something measurable in return. A vague introductory discount with no end point teaches customers to treat the lower number as the normal price.
Repeated discounting can also hide the true amount you keep from each transaction. Fees, free extras, extended payment terms, shipping, support, and revisions can reduce the realized price far below the amount shown on the original quote. Review the money retained after every concession, not just the amount printed on the invoice.
Consider adding value before reducing price. A simpler onboarding process, clearer deliverables, scheduled support, a bundled option, or a faster payment method can improve the offer without weakening the base rate. If a customer needs a lower total, reduce scope, quantity, speed, or access so the economics remain balanced.
How Often Should You Review Your Pricing?
Review pricing at least quarterly during the early stage of a business, then adjust the schedule as costs and demand become more predictable. You should also review it whenever your offer, customer group, delivery cost, or capacity changes.
Start the review with actual transaction data. Compare the quoted price with the money collected after discounts, fees, refunds, delivery expenses, and unpaid extras. Calculate direct cost, gross margin, time spent, and contribution toward overhead for each main product or service. Averages can hide weak customers or packages, so review individual transaction types as well.
Examine customer demand without treating every objection as proof that your rate is wrong. Track proposal acceptance, repeat purchases, requests for discounts, cancellations, and the reasons customers choose you. Compare performance across packages and customer groups. A rate that works for one buyer type may fail with another because their needs and willingness to pay differ.
End the audit with a decision. Keep the price, raise it, change the package, narrow the customer group, control discounts, or reduce delivery costs. Record the reason and choose a future review point so pricing doesn’t become a forgotten decision. Regular reviews let you correct small leaks before they become permanent habits.
What Is The Most Common Pricing Mistake New Businesses Make?
- New businesses often underprice by copying competitors or marking up incomplete costs.
- Low prices reduce margins, strain cash flow, and attract price-sensitive buyers.
- Set prices from full costs, customer value, and a planned profit.
Build A Price That Supports The Business You Want
Underpricing new businesses can create the appearance of momentum without the financial strength needed to maintain it. Your price has to cover visible delivery costs, hidden work, overhead, owner compensation, and profit. Use competitor rates for comparison, not imitation, and connect your final number to the value customers receive. Review discounts and transaction costs so you know what each sale actually contributes. A sustainable price won’t remove every difficult decision, but it gives your business room to serve customers well, handle setbacks, and grow without depending on constant overwork.
References
- McKinsey & Company: The Power of Pricing
- CB Insights: Why Startups Fail, Top Reasons
- Harvard Business Review: Pricing Strategy
- QuickBooks: Cost-Plus Pricing
- QuickBooks: Competitive Pricing Strategies
- SCORE: Financial Matters For New Businesses.
Olivier Gillier is a global investment strategist and co-founder of RioBlanco Capital LLC, with over 20 years of experience in wealth management and international markets. A former Senior Vice President at Merrill Lynch, he now focuses on private equity, cross-border finance, and philanthropic initiatives worldwide.

